Did you hear Phil Savages press conference yesterday? It was great. For a number of reasons. In general, Phil Savage sounded like the guy we all hope he is: focused on getting good players and strong in his convictions. And you get the sense why, despite all of John Collins maneuvering, Savages approach won the day last week in Berea.
A couple main points Savage made:
- He comes from a scouting background, and scouting will be the backbone of the player acquisition philosophy. Ive never been so happy to hear someone state what should be obvious.
- Negotiating player contracts is a key part of player acquisition. Its funny -- if you have listened to sports talk radio for the last 10 years it would be obvious that how a contract is structured is vitally important and a huge factor in even being able to pursue certain players. Savage matter-of-factly pointed out that a GM who does not have responsibility for this is not actually a GM.
- He made some comments about specific players and whether the Browns would resign them. In talking about Antonio Bryant he made clear the Browns have some interest but only at the right price, and alluded to waiting to see how the market played out. In doing so I think he gave everyone some evidence that hes not a novice when it comes to negotiations and contracts. Another example would be how the Browns tried to extend Orpheus Roye before the end of the season but when it became clear they could not agree to terms they quickly moved to get Leigh Bodden wrapped up instead.
- He never got into any conflict with Collins. Instead he talked about how he continued to do his job. That was probably a bit of spin, but it also sounded like a bit of his philosophy on how to be effective in the madcap world of the NFL.
- Even though he avoided details, he never described things like the doing Braylon Edwards contract as being some otherworldy, unbelievably complicated accomplishment. His attitude was more, "yeah, its not always easy to do these deals but thats the way it goes." Contrast that with all those self-satisfied press conferences we got over the years from Butch and Policy.
While I was listening to the press conference on WTAM, Mike Trivasano talked over the broadcast and some something like, "You know we could keep broadcasting this but frankly I find this pretty boring, dont you?" and then went to break. So I, like thousands of other listeners, promptly switched over the WKNR for the rest of the press conference. Later on I tuned back to WTAM to hear Triv go on and on about how Savage was not saying anything of value and how Savage and Lerner dont have the balls to come on his program and "set the record straight" and how Jim Brown had no problem doing that.
Hey Triv -- you are a freaking idiot.
- First off, listening to Jim Brown on Friday Dec 30th it was OBVIOUS Jim Brown had no idea what was happening within the Browns as he hadnt even heard about reports of Savages imminent firing. Despite that, you let him talk aimlessly on the air for a solid hour without advancing the story one bit. it was comically bad radio. And you wallowed in it like a pig in mud. Is there anything you wont do for access? It was pathetic.
- Last week you were all over the place saying you "broke" the story that Savage would stay despite the fact the word was all over the internet many hours before you went on air with it. Despite that, WTAM continued to lead with "As reported earlier by Mike Trivasano..." PATHETIC. And since when did you start calling yourself a reporter?
- The press conference was anything but boring. In fact, it was extremely interesting and refreshing.
- Perhaps you should consider that Lerner and Savage dont want to come on your show. Why would they? There are plenty of media outlets to get the company line out on. So maybe they dont want to talk to you because they dont want to be subjected to continually dumb-ass questions about what the "real story" is. Or maybe they are repulsed by your attempted saddling up next to them to get the "inside scoop." Or maybe there just isnt an "inside scoop" to get because they dont want to operate that way. Or maybe they see you as a relic from the Carmen Policy days where you shoveled what ever he crapped out on your doorstep? Or maybe they see PatMac or even Grossi and realize they are far better messengers if they want to talk to the media? Or maybe you are a freaking cry baby? Grow up!
- Hey I have an idea, maybe you could get together a bunch of former Browns and just ask them whats going on in Berea. That way you get get gossippy info and it cant be any less accurate that what Jim Brown tells you!
The fact that Maurice Carthon is being interviewed for head coaching vacancies is kind of ridiculous, isnt it? While the intent of the "Rooney Rule" is good, how does interviewing candidates who are clearly not yet qualified help anyone? Personally, I am really split on the value of this. Its cool that guys are getting interviews. But its insulting to minority candidates if they to have to go through a couple years of you-have-no-chance interviews before they are really going to be taken seriously. The whole thing seems like a hoop to make guys jump through. Grossi says that "
Carthons exposure to the interview process is an example of the Rooney Rule working," but I wonder what "working" means in this case if NFL GMs and owners arent actually viewing Carthon as a legitimate candidate. Im not quite saying that the rule should be changed, but I wouldnt blame minority coaches if they approached suck Rooney-interviews with a certain degree of cynicism.
It sounds like Roye resigning with the Browns is probable. Thatd be cool. Then wed need only 2 more defensive linemen. Hopefully we can get at least one legit guy this offseason.
Let me go on the record to say that Herman Edwards being "traded" to the Chiefs is just not a very big deal, unless you are part of Herms immediate family in which case you can expect a giant windfall of cash. Edwards is a good head coach, but hes never really won much of anything. The Chiefs are a great organization but still have some issues to work out on the field, particularly at quarterback. And the whining of New York media types about how horrible it is for the NFL to allow head coaches to orchestrate their own trades is kind of stupid since 1) its only now a problem now that it happens to a New York team, 2) its only now a problem when a New York team only gets a 4th round pick in return, and 3) the NFL is a SPORTS LEAGUE where theres nothing wrong with trading any damn thing that teams want to. Someone needs to tell Peter King ("What has happened here is an outrage.") to chill out and remember that Herm Edwards, today, has merely been the coach of five mediocre teams, not a bona fide Super Bowl winning coach.
Troy Polamalu is a moron. I realize some players get jacked up for the game and that helps them play better, but cmon. You can be fiercely competitive, but being a jerk on top of it is your choice Troy.
Sean Taylor is an a$$hole. Id rather have Kellen Winslow than Taylor. What a jerk, and it didnt start this past weekend.
I cant for the life of me why anyone would draft Marcus Vick. Heck, if you could draft _Mike_ Vick now, where would you pick him? Would he even go in the first round? I dont think there is any guarantee that he would go that high, and I personally wouldnt want him unless he fell into the late rounds. Athleticism is a great thing to have for a QB. But you absolutely must have a degree of discipline. And without that you cant win on a regular basis. Mike Vick is getting better, but still has a ways to go. Marcus Vick hasnt shown anything that should give NFL teams reason to hope. ...that said, I hope the Ravens select him.
Speaking of QBs, it will be very interesting to see how much interest Chris Simms garners on the free agent market. He is not a worldbeater, but a team can win with him. And it is rare that a young QB like that becomes a free agent.
Suddenly the Bengals seem to be in trouble. Besides the fact that Carson Palmer will still be rehabbing when next season starts, PFT reports that Chad Johnson had an altertaction with his WR coach at halftime the other day, then took a swing at Marvin Lewis. Youd think that might buy Johnson a ticket out of town. The Bengals arent good enough yet to overcome losing their two best offensive weapons, and its an open question how well a rehabbing Palmer would fair without his playmaking wide receiver.
Last year I was all for hiring Russ Grimm as Browns head coach, or at least giving him a serious look. Im thrilled with Romeo now, but interested to see if Grimm gets a shot. Supposedly the Lions are interested. Note to Russ: Stay away. Not only are the Lions a mess personnel-wise, it is a situation where fans have unrealistic expectations of short-term success. And it will take time to turn that team into a squad where the linemen dominate.
Tim Couch got a look from the Dolphins. Isnt it time for someone to take a shot again on Couch? I mean, hed reportedly been working out and ready to roll this past season and no one bit. I think that has to do with the fact that hes just not that smart of a player and teams cant count on him learning a system fast enough. But this offseason Id think he gets back in the league and gets his last best shot.
National Championship notes:
Is there something Im not seeing about Reggie Bush? Hes explosive, sure, but he seems kind of small and doesnt even look durable. I cant see him being an every down back in the NFL, and I cant see him being as effective going up against faster, more athletic defenders. He might be the Michael Vick of NFL running backs, or perhaps the Desmond Howard of running backs, and that doesnt seem worth the #1 overall pick. Not unless he can really get stronger.
If I were Houston Id pick Vince Young in a second. Hes the best player -- hes big, durable, athletic and could get a lot better. Hes not a great passer yet, but hes pretty good, even with a funky delivery. The only thing Id worry about is whether hes ready to take on the challenge of reading NFL defenses. He wasnt exactly the type of college QB who would make a blitzing defense pay by throwing to the hot receiver, and he really relied on his legs to pick up chunks of yardage while under pressure. In the NFL I can see him continuing to use his legs -- to buy time and to shake off tacklers. He wont be the next Tom Brady, but he reminds me a little of Steve McNair in that he is so big and strong that one guy can rarely take him down. Except young is much speedier and more nimble.
Matt Leinart will be a decent pro, though hes not going to blow anyone away physically. But that isnt necessarily a handicap if it means he needs to focus on the mental aspects of the game. If I were a GM Id really do my homework on him to see whether hes the type of guy who will committ to a system; you cant count on the superior talent level of your playmakers in the NFL. Not a sure thing, but still a good bet for a club that needs a QB. And he ought not to have a problem being in the spotlight, thats for sure.
If there was one player in the national championship game Id like to have on my team its LenDale White. What a monster! He ran with power and speed. And the guy looked like he was ready to play THIS Sunday. I know the Browns dont need a running back, but you couldnt complain if they selected him. He certainly seems to me to be a better NFL prospect than Bush, even if he specializes in great straight-ahead running instead of drool-inducing highlights.
I dont know where, but somewhere on that Texas defensive line is a 2006 NFL starter. Although USC seemed to have their way running the ball for much of the game, Texas really stuffed them when it was clear USC had to gain half a yard. That was the difference in the game.
Overall, a great game. A lot like last years Rose Bowl between Texas and Michigan where you just knew the Michigan defense couldnt handle Vince Young. Except Young was noticeably more accurate throwing the ball.